Take a look at our menu to get a better idea of the fresh and delicious options we have for pickup, delivery, or dine-in! We are happy to serve you the best pizza in Erie, PA, whether you are coming to us or we are bringing it to you!
All our pizzas are made from the freshest hand-tossed dough. We make our dough daily and it shows. No premade or frozen crusts here which truly makes for the best pizza around! We hope you enjoy our delicious wood fired pizzas!
ENJOY OUR WOOD FIRED PIZZA AND CLASSIC NY THIN CRUST PIZZAS
We specialize in NY Thin Crust Pizzas. We are also known for our delicious wood fired pizzas in the Erie, PA area. Currently, we don't have thick crust or a Gluten-Free option. Maybe in the future.
Small Pizza (10 in.)
Our Small 10-inch pie is a perfect size for 1. The pie comes with sauce and cheese. Each additional Traditional Topping is 90¢ and Gourmet Toppings are $1.39 each.
Medium Cheese (14 in.)
Our Medium 14-inch pie is what others call a "Large". The pie comes with sauce and cheese. Each additional Traditional Topping is $1.69 and Gourmet Toppings are $2.20 each. Sunday Special: each Medium 1 Topping Pizza is ONLY $9.25 (min of 3 pies).
Large Cheese (18 in.)
This is our Large 18-inch pizza, and not too many places in Erie even make an18-inch pizza. The pie comes with sauce and cheese. Each additional Traditional Topping is $2.15 and Gourmet Toppings are $3.59 each. Tuesday Special: each Large 4 Topping Pizza Is ONLY $18 Ea.
XL Cheese (24 in.)
Not only is this the largest pizza that we make, but it is also the LARGEST in Erie. Our XL 24-inch pie is 2 feet X 2 feet of pizza happiness. The pie comes with sauce and cheese. Each additional Traditional Topping is $3.89 and Gourmet Toppings are $6.55 each. Thursday Special: each XL 2 Topping Pizza is ONLY $24.50 ea.
Our XL pizza is what the PIZZA CHALLANGE is all about. Think you can finish it?
Pepperoni, Extra Cheese, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Red Peppers, Sausage, Black Olives, Fresh Tomato, Red Onions, Bacon, Broccoli, Garlic, Ham, Salami, Ricotta, Fresh Basil, Cheddar/Jack Cheese, Pineapple, Banana Peppers, Jalapenos, Spinach
Can't decide? This is a Garbage Pizza. We put whatever WE want on it. It’s all the "garbage" under the Brooklyn Bridge. Please let us know if there is something that you really don't want or can't have. It goes great with our Brooklyn Bridge Fries.
NY Calzones: add additional toppings to any calzone. $1 each topping for small and $2 per topping on large.
*Small | Large
The Classic Calzone - $7 | $14
The Classic comes with ricotta, mozzarella, pepperoni and salami.
Pepperoni Calzone - $8 | $15.50
The Pepperoni Calzone comes with sauce, mozzarella and lots of pepperoni.
Our heroes come on a white or wheat roll in either 7 inches or 10 inches. All heroes come with a pickle.
*Small | Large
Original Philly Cheesesteak - $6.50 | $8.50
Shaved steak, red peppers, green peppers, red onions and provolone cheese.
Meatball Hero - $6 | $8
Lots of meatballs, sauce, provolone, parmesan and Italian seasonings.
Italian - $5.75 | $7.50
Ham, salami, pepperoni, Italian dressing, lettuce, tomato and onion.
Club on a Sub - $5.75 | $7.50
Sliced turkey, ham and crispy bacon topped with pepperjack cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion.
No Sleep Till Brooklyn - $5.75 | $7.50
Sliced turkey, sautéed mushrooms and melted Swiss topped with lettuce, tomato and onion.
Chicken Parmesan - $6 | $8
Crispy tenders, marinara, provolone and Italian seasonings.
Classic BLT - $5.75 | $7.50
Lots of crispy bacon, fresh sliced tomato, crisp lettuce and mayo.
Turkey Bacon Ranch - $6.50 | $8.50
Sliced turkey, crispy bacon, cheddar jack cheese, topped with Ranch dressing and lettuce, tomato and onion.
Old Faithful - $5.75 | $7.50
Choose a turkey or ham sandwich with your choice of cheese and lettuce, tomato and onion.
*Small | Large
House Salad - $3.25 | $5.35
Our salads come with mixed lettuce, red onion, fresh tomato and cheddar/jack cheese. Dressings include ranch, French, Italian, bleu cheese and honey mustard. Add turkey, ham, steak, grilled or crispy chicken to any salad: Sm. ($1) | Lg. ($1.45).
Antipasto Salad - $5.79 | $7.99
Chopped lettuce, black olives, fresh mozzarella, provolone, salami, pepperoni, pepperoncini, stuffed green olives, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, fresh mushrooms, capicola and parmesan with Italian dressing.
The BIG Salad - $4 | $6
Garden salad with green peppers, red peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, pepperoni, cheddar jack cheese and pepperoncini.
Spinach Salad - $4 |$ 6
Lots of fresh spinach, walnuts, feta cheese and dried cranberries with your choice of dressing.
*Small | Large
Choose from regular ($5.25), Garlic ($5.55) or Cheesy ($6.65) Breadsticks.
6 knots covered in garlic and butter along with marinara sauce for dipping. Order them baked or fried.
Choose either white or wheat bread. 10-inch roll cut in half, covered in butter and garlic and baked to a perfect crispiness. Comes with 2 sides of marinara sauce.
Our Pepperoni Balls are filled with lots of pepperoni and are baked or fried. Always made to order so it might take a few minutes.
Pizza balls are just like the pepperoni balls only with cheese and sauce. These can only be baked, and are always made to order.
5 mozzarella sticks and 2 sides of marinara sauce for dipping.
Chicken Tenders with Fries
4 Crispy chicken tenders and a handful of fries. Comes with ranch. Substitute BBQ or honey mustard BBQand ketchup.
Basket of 5 jalapeno poppers filled with cheddar cheese and 2 sides of Ranch for dipping.
3 Mozzarella sticks, 2 fried pepperoni balls, 3 chicken tenders and 2 jalapeno poppers. It comes with 2 sides of ranch, BBQ sauce and 1 marinara sauce.
Add cheese to a Small for $1 or Large for $1.35 (mozzarella, provolone, cheddar/jack, Swiss or pepperjack).
$3.55 | $4.75
Brooklyn Bridge Fries
Just like our Brooklyn Bridge Pizza, whatever we want toput on them. It’s all the garbage under the bridge.
$5 | $7
A large basket of Fries topped with steak, green peppers, red peppers and onions and provolone cheese.
Plain ($2.55) or chocolate-covered cannolis($2.75).
$2.55 | $2.75
Plain NY-style cheesecake, Red Velvet, Triple Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Caramel Turtle of Mississippi Mudslide.
Mini plain cannolis. They come in 2- or 3-packs.
$2 | $3
We serve Coke products including Coke Classic, Diet Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Fanta Orange, Fuze Lemon Tea, Barq's Root Beer and Cherry Coke.
2 Liter $2.40
20 oz. Bottles $1.85
20 oz. Water $1.85
Slush Puppie $1.80 | $2.15
Hire the Fire
Thank you for contacting us. We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Oops, there was an error sending your message. Please try again later.